EP 19: The Search for Jordan Naterer in Manning Park

EP 19: The Search for Jordan Naterer in Manning Park

[00:00:00] - [Nina]
In a picturesque landscape, rapidly shifting weather can turn a peaceful getaway into a dangerous situation fast. Today's episode is a story of a brilliant young man's misadventure. The pain his loved ones felt of not knowing what happened and the parental devotion that carried the search for answers for months. This is episode 19, the search for Jordan Naterer in Manning Park. Welcome to Mishaps and Mysteries.

[00:00:32] - [Cassie]
I'm your host, Nina. And I'm your host, Cassie. Our podcast explores stories of misadventures in the wild landscapes of British Columbia, Canada. Thanks for being here with us today. Content warning.

[00:00:49] - [Cassie]
Today's episode will have discussions of death and human remains. Please take care when listening.

[00:00:56] - [Nina]
EC Manning Provincial Park is one of BC's most popular parks, bringing in over 100,000,000 visitors each year. At over 83.5 hectares, it's another large wilderness park like similar ones we've brought you stories from in past episodes. Established in 1941, it's named after Ernest Calloway Manning. He was the chief forester of BC at the time and had died in a plane crash. Like Cathedral Provincial Park in episode 17, the park's southern end rests on the Canada US border.

[00:01:35] - [Nina]
It lies Southeast Of Hope and surrounds the Similkameen River. The park's landscape includes mountain and valley terrain, transitions from the western hemlock forest to the dry mountain landscape of the interior. It also contains a forest of golden larches that are 2,000 years old. The thing with EC Manning is it's such a well known park because many of us have passed through it on road trips. Highway 3 or Crow's Nest Highway cuts right through the park, so it's a popular spot to just pull over and have a rest on your drive.

[00:02:14] - [Cassie]
That's the first thing that comes to mind for me when I think of Manning Park.

[00:02:18] - [Nina]
And in fact, the design of the park and the development of the highway in the nineteen forties were tied together for this very reason. As an era of road travel for leisure was just beginning, scenic enjoyment on the drive was a priority. And not many provincial parks have this in BC, but it also contains a resort. Researching the story, the resort looks amazing. There's year round activities to do here from summertime camping, hiking, horseback riding, and water activities to winter skiing and skating.

[00:02:54] - [Nina]
Truly an adventurous playground.

[00:03:05] - [Cassie]
It was October 10, 2020 when Jordan Natterer set out on a two day solo hike in the frosty mountain area of Manning Park. Remember 2020?

[00:3:18] - [Nina] COVID

[00:03:20] - [Cassie]
Yeah. We were all living through it then. Kind of all blurred together now. So Jordan Naterer was from Newfoundland and Labrador and was 25 years old. He was described by his mother as quote, a brilliant young talented man with an enormous heart. He stood five ten with a slim build and short brown hair. His parents were Greg and Josie Naterer.

[00:03:46] - [Cassie]
His dad was the dean of engineering University in St. John's, Newfoundland, and his mom Josie was a fundraising specialist with a background in public relations. Jordan had followed in his dad's footsteps and gone on to gain an engineering degree from Memorial University and then a graduate degree in engineering from the University of British Columbia, which is what had brought him to our side of the country away from where he'd grown up. He lived in Downtown Vancouver. He was seen leaving his apartment on Saturday, October 10, and was wearing black pants, white running shoes, and an olive green backpack.

[00:04:33] - [Cassie]
From there, he left in his Honda Civic for the approximately two point five hour drive to Manning Park. Jordan was reported missing after he never showed up to a Thanksgiving dinner party on Monday, 10/12/2020. His friends couldn't get ahold of him and knew that this wasn't like him. He hadn't left a trip plan, but he had mentioned to friends his plans of hiking in Manning Park. Investigators were able to trace his movements and confirm that he had last made a purchase of a cup of coffee at Manning Park Resort.

[00:05:09] - [Cassie]
When they searched the park, they found a Honda Civic was parked at the Frosty Mountain Trailhead. The Frosty Mountain Trail is considered to be a difficult hike, a 21 kilometer journey that brings hikers to the highest peak in Manning Park. Views from the mountain trail include some stunning scenery of the river valley and all the way up to an alpine barren rocky ridgeline. And that gold larch forest Nina just mentioned, the trail takes hikers right along that setting. It's a beautiful place, but also an inherently risky wilderness that had now swallowed up a young man.

[00:05:50] - [Cassie]
Where was Jordan?

[00:06:00] - [Nina]
The search for Jordan had begun. This was an area known for unpredictable weather, sparking immediate concerns for his safety. An early season storm had just hit in the time that he had been gone. 150 personnel from seven search and rescue teams across the province traversed Manning Park. The search also included UAVs, thermal imaging, dogs, and three hundred hours of flight time by three helicopters.

[00:06:32] - [Nina]
Since this was an overnight hiking trip, there was a large distance to cover. And he was also more prepared to make it through the night given overnight gear he had with him. After he was reported missing, his parents flew out straight away from Newfoundland. In the investigation, police were able to determine that there was a ping from his cell phone on October 10 at 12:30PM, placing his last known location on the Windy Joe Trail, four kilometers south of Manning Park Resort. The search went on for five days.

[00:07:07] - [Nina]
It ended October 17. After the official search was called off, the Naterer family launched a petition to get the search going again. And they also launched a GoFundMe for private search expenses. They felt that because he'd been prepared for two days, the search should have lasted longer, that there was possibility he was still alive. They were frustrated with the Vancouver police feeling that there was good reason to keep the search going.

[00:07:40] - [Nina]
The Naterer's were vocal about how they felt and what they wanted to see done. They knew that their son was smart and prepared and that he wouldn't give up easily.

[00:07:51] - [Cassie]
Just after the search was called off, things took a sharp turn. On October 18, the day after the search was stood down, a bag was found by a hiker just south of Frosty Peak in late October. To be clear, it wasn't a backpack, it was just a bag. At first, searchers believed it did not belong to Jordan, but it did contain items that Josie was able to identify as his, including Oakley sunglasses and a white hat. There were also footprints nearby.

[00:08:24] - [Cassie]
There were pieces of down material found in the park too. Apparently, Jordan used down for crafts. What exactly for, we're not sure, but material like this was found in his apartment. The new evidence was found in an area that had not been searched very much or very well according to reports. There was speculation that he was traveling from Windy Joe Mountain to Frosty Mountain, sort of doing the trail in reverse.

[00:08:55] - [Cassie]
Both hit Frosty Mountain, and they can be done as a loop. The idea behind this was that he was maybe trying to get to a campground faster. If you look at these two trails on a map and imagine Jordan being possibly somewhere in the loop that they create, well, it's a huge and rugged mountainous terrain with large drainages. With the evidence of Jordan's movements and a new area to hone in on, the Naterer's pleaded with Vancouver police to reignite the search for Jordan. The investigation fell under the VPD's jurisdiction because that's where Jordan had been residing.

[00:09:41] - [Cassie]
Three search and rescue teams from the area started the search again, but VPD crews did not return to the park until October 22 because this is when the weather was better for drone searches. So let's do a quick review of the timeline here. On October 10, Jordan leaves Vancouver for his trip to Manning. One thing we want to add in here was that he was seen by a witness about forty minutes into the frosty mountain trail. That was the last sighting of him.

[00:10:16] - [Cassie]
October 12 October 12, Jordan is reported missing by his friends. On October 17, the search is called off. October 18, the bag is found and the items inside are identified as his. Searchers go back out, and on October 22 the police are out with drones. At this point, Jordan has not been seen since October 10 by that witness in the park.

[00:10:49] - [Cassie]
He has been missing for twelve days. And after this, it seems that the Naterer's were generally on their own with their private search efforts. National attention was given to this case. You had two provinces involved that couldn't be further apart. You had the province where the mystery of a mountain disappearance was unfolding, and the other province worried for one of their own.

[00:11:20] - [Cassie]
Late October, the story caught the attention of then prime minister Justin Trudeau. Now this is not something that I knew until recently, Nina, but Justin Trudeau's own brother had died in an avalanche accident in BC in 1998. So it seems that this case really hit home for him.

[00:11:40] - [Nina]
I actually remember that, Cass, because I was in Prince George at the time.

[00:11:44] - [Cassie]
Yeah. It must have been really big news. Yeah. It was. He said he couldn't hear the story and not think of his younger brother, Michel.

[00:11:53] - [Cassie]
We've added Michel's story to our case catalog to cover in the future. So all of this was unfolding in the headlines in autumn of twenty twenty when COVID otherwise dominated them. Jordan's case captivated many as hope was held that he would be found.

[00:12:20] - [Nina]
So without much help from the Vancouver police, the private search went on for weeks. But, unfortunately, nothing of Jordan was found. This wasn't easy terrain, especially getting up into those mountains. Josie even fell, injuring herself at one point during the search. Apparently, it was fairly serious.

[00:12:42] - [Nina]
His dad stayed in BC, took a leave of absence from his job, and took part in the search on a daily basis. Josie eventually had to make the tough journey back home across the country without her son, but kept up efforts from afar. She ran through large amounts of drone footage and took part in organizing the search and obtaining maps and keeping the story in the news and on social media. By mid November, over $127,000 had been raised on GoFundMe to help pay for the search. But with winter conditions only worsening in the park and plenty of snowfall having occurred since his disappearance, the parents of Jordan were now both home in Newfoundland.

[00:13:30] - [Nina]
The feeling of just sitting at home, twiddling their thumbs on the other side of the nation was unsettling for them as it would be for anyone. They had to know what happened to their son. Theories about what happened were abundant. There was no indication of Jordan being involved in anything dangerous. Foul play was not believed to be a factor here.

[00:13:56] - [Nina]
Had Jordan simply gotten lost, eventually falling victim to the elements, or was he attacked by a wild animal? Maybe he fell or had another kind of accident and was awaiting rescue. Everyone following the case was simply left to wonder.

[00:14:22] - [Cassie]
The family had kept search efforts strong since October 2020. Eager to keep looking, Greg was on his leave of absence and went back in February to resume searching. He hiked in the park constantly to look for any signs of Jordan. Especially as spring melt began, there was hope that new clues would be uncovered. Fast forward to Sunday, 07/04/2021, so the summer after he went missing.

[00:14:55] - [Cassie]
Jordan's backpack and other belongings were found by a volunteer searcher. The backpack contained a sleeping bag, red jacket, tent poles, and a charger and food. There were no wallet, keys, or phone found. This helped set a search alight again. They were able to set up a grid search based on the items found so far.

[00:15:24] - [Cassie]
Search and rescue groups were then back out. And on Tuesday, July 6, human remains were found by a volunteer searcher. The discovery was far down in a gully. And you know where this is going. Sadly, the human remains were confirmed to be those of 25 year old Jordan Naterer.

[00:15:49] - [Cassie]
And what really stood out here was this gully was four kilometers from where his backpack was found. Meaning Jordan was assumed to have been traversing the difficult landscape in the ugly stormy weather of mid October, looking for a way out of his predicament, whatever that was. In the end, his resting place was just a 100 meters from the trail. It is believed that the winter storm that had rolled in had pushed him down into the gully, perhaps seeking shelter or at least a windbreak from the elements, and then he struggled to find a way out.

[00:16:35] - [Nina]
In the aftermath of finding their son's remains, Greg Naterer wrote a memoir about his time looking for Jordan in Manning Park and the surrounding area titled called by mother earth, a father search for his son. And it takes readers through the whole experience of learning of Jordan's disappearance to the search for months to grief. We've linked the book in our show notes and hope to do a future episode diving into the book and the experience of being a parent of a missing person. It's such a complex experience. The mix of hope and dread and we can only imagine.

[00:17:18] - [Nina]
For today's safety lesson, we've got two pieces. First, why did Jordan separate from his pack? Well, we'll never truly know. But the most common reasons people ditch their pack are they feel it's weighing them down or slowing them down and that they would be able to move better without it, or they are disoriented and maybe not making good decisions. We've touched on it before, but stay with your pack or whatever it is you have on you.

[00:17:48] - [Nina]
You never know what you're going to need. Just like Lynn and Rick shared in last week's episode. Jordan had important equipment that he needed for the cold, such as a sleeping bag with a proper warmth rating and a down jacket. The next safety tip is very specific, and we hope this never happens to you. But if anyone you love is ever missing, stay annoying.

[00:18:13] - [Nina]
You know, they say the squeaky wheel gets the grease. If there's one thing Cass and I have learned from following and covering these cases, it's just how critical it is to keep a name in the spotlight. Bug whoever you can for answers and for updates. The heartbreak and longing for answers that parents of a missing child feel is like nothing else, and this family did not give up. They spent their time dedicated to finding what happened to their son.

[00:18:43] - [Nina]
They called out the police for ending the search too early. They had petitions and a fundraiser and kept the search going and the story in the media. And even today with a memoir, Jordan's story is alive. In the end,

[00:18:58] - [Cassie]
Jordan's family got some answers. They had the very human desire to lay their loved one to rest. They got closure, but they'll always be left to wonder exactly what happened. They are forever left to mourn the life of their brilliant and kind son who disappeared while just out enjoying nature on the other side of the country. We want to leave you today with the words of his father, Greg.

[00:19:32] - [Cassie]
After accidentally losing the hiking trail in unexpected blizzard conditions, Jordan was funneled down into a treacherous drainage basin. He struggled in the dark through steep terrain with massive tree downfall over several kilometers in a valiant effort to escape the drainages. When our search team eventually found some of his hiking gear and Jordan's final resting place, it was difficult to comprehend how someone could have traveled that distance in those conditions. Only a superstar like my son, a proud Newfoundlander, could have made such a heroic effort.

[00:20:16] - [Nina]
Thank you for joining us for this episode. New episodes are out every Tuesday. You can reach out to us at info@mishapsandmysteries.ca. If you enjoy this episode, subscribe and leave us a rating and a review. It really helps new people find us.

[00:20:33] - [Nina]
Also, share with your friends. Be safe and never stop exploring.

Search and Rescue,Missing Persons,Jordan Naterer,Manning Park,